Sunday, July 1, 2012

Is Italy's Culture Killing Its Economy? Is Ours Killing Ours?

Take a few moments to read this interesting piece from this morning's WaPost by Steven Pearlstein about some of the problems bedeviling the Italian economy as it attempts to reform itself.  Then, read the comments that follow.  Was there a disconnect between what you had read and understood and what most of the comments had to say?

As I read the article and the sins it laid out, I thought to myself "wait--that's us too".  Read this passage in particular and tell me if it doesn't describe our bifurcated economy too:

"There’s the one that is composed of several thousand large and medium-size firms, mostly in the northern half of the country, that are innovative, efficient, internationally competitive exporters that generate wealth and high wages and whose productivity and employment have been steadily growing. And then there is the part, much of it in the south, composed of government, small family companies, government-owned enterprises, utilities, banks and lumbering corporate giants that largely operate in protected or uncompetitive domestic markets. Their productivity has fallen every year for decades."  Then there is this:  "Worse still, the trend lines are going in the wrong direction: The unproductive parts are growing while the productive parts — the people and the companies — are moving elsewhere."

I read this and I think "Obama".  I think of public sector unions, or unions in general.  I think "California", "Illinois".  While there may be cultural aspects to how the problems manifest themselves in Italy, the problems are not that much different than the problems that bedevil us.

Then one reads the comments, and it is like a whole different story was being discussed.  A great deal of anti-Republican, anti-Capitalist, anti-Romney, anti-Bush and....anti-American rhetoric is there.  How DARE the author criticize a system in which the family is so venerated.  How DARE he criticize a society that gives its people productivity strangling vacation time.  The comment section turns largely into a venue to criticize OUR system, while looking at the perennial basket case that is Italy and holding it up for praise.

We may be doomed, folks.


Anonymous said...

Il Washington Post รจ la puttana dei Democratici. Teste cazzo totale

Tom de Plume said...

I love this one:

"I wonder if it has occurred to Mr. Pearlstein that he could rewrite the article and substitute "the US" for Italy and "Appalachia and Dixie" for the Mezzogiorno?"

Couldn't we just substitute Detroit, East St. Louis, of Camden, NJ? Or would that be an invalid comparison because Mezzogiomo doesn't enjoy an 80% illegitimacy rate and 4 generations suckling on the public teat?

Newer Post Older Post Home